Ice Cream Cakes + Pies
Custom Cakes
(Order Form Can Be Found At The Bottom Of This Page)
What's In A Cake?
Your cake can include up to three of any of our current flavors of Ice Cream! We would be happy to add a layer of chocolate or yellow cake at the bottom for an additional charge. The cake is approximately 1/4 inch thick. You may also choose an edible image
for an additional charge, please email us your desired image to Cakes@theplushhorse.com
Last day to order custom cakes this week is...
Thursday at noon for the upcoming weekend.
CLOSED ON MONDAY'S JANUARY-MARCH
Pony Sheet $35
Serves 8-10
1/2 Sheet Cake $75
Serves 40 - 44
1/4 Sheet Cake $57
Serves 20 - 24
Baby Cake $11
Serves 1 - 2
6" Cake $30
Serves 6 - 8
9" Cake $48
Serves 18 - 20
9" Pie $18-22
Serves 10-12
Specialty Shape
~Heart **call for price.
Our Current CUSTOM Decoration Will Include:
Ice Cream -> with no cake, chocolate or yellow cake
- Up To 3 Flavors (Up to 2 Flavors For Mini Cakes). Sheet Cakes Will Have Flavors Side By Side ONLY
- (Whip Cream is Dairy Free. Contains Soy)
- Your Custom Greeting
- Specific colored border only or sprinkles.
(Border made with whip cream only)
- Candy add-on upon request
(extra charge per cake size).
- Edible image upon request
(extra charge per cake size).
Flavors
-
Coffee
-
Cookie Dough
-
Cookies & Cream
-
Cookie Monster Blue
-
Cotton Candy
-
Dark Chocolate
-
English Toffee
-
Hawaiian Delight
-
Honey Lavender
-
Jameson Gelato
-
Maple Nut
-
Mint Chip
-
Moose Tracks
-
Peach
-
Peppermint
-
Pistachio Nut
-
Rainbow Sherbet
-
Rocky Road
-
Rum Raisin
-
Strawberry
-
Strawberry Cheesecake
-
Superman
-
Sweet Caroline
-
Vanilla
-
Vanilla NSA(No Sugar Added)
-
Vanilla Malt
-
White Cookie Monster
-
DAIRY FREE - extra charge
NSA = No Sugar Added
Whip Cream topping contains: SOY
Flavors In Pink Change Seasonally. Call for Availability.
**See our FLAVOR PAGE for more seasonal flavors!
-
Almond Amaretto
-
Apple Pie
-
Bailey's Gelato
-
Banana
-
Banana Fudge Gelato
-
Black Cherry
-
Black Walnut
-
Blue Moon
-
Brownie Batter
-
Bubble Gum
-
Butter Finger
-
Butter Pecan
-
Butter Pecan NSA(No Sugar Added)
-
Cake Batter
-
Cappuccino
-
Caramel Sea Salt Gelato
-
Cherry Vanilla
-
Cherry Vanilla NSA(No Sugar Added)
-
Chicago Pot Hole
-
Chocolate
-
Chocolate Chip
-
Chocolate Chocolate Chip
-
Chocolate Hazelnut
-
Chocolate Malt
-
Chocolate Mousse
-
Chocolate Peanut Butter
-
Coconut Gelato
-
Coconut Fudge Gelato
-
Cinnamon
For DAIRY-FREE OPTIONS
Email us for a quote at
cakes@theplushhorse.com
*ONLINE ORDERS REQUIRE AT LEAST 48-72 HOURS*
CUSTOM ORDER CUT-OFF FOR WEEKEND PICKUP:
Thursday at 12 noon
(cut -off time & day may change throughout the year)
CLOSED ON MONDAY'S JANUARY-MARCH
We also offer a variety of ready-made Display cakes in our Freezer!
Display cakes are ice cream only (no cake included).
Pick Up Inside At Palos Park
ALLERGIES?
Let us know upon ordering so that we can properly accommodate your needs.
*Our product is processed on machinery that was used to process products containing Eggs, Peanuts, Tree Nuts, Wheat, Barley and Rye..
*We are not a 100% Allergy free establishment.