top of page

Ice Cream Cakes + Pies

Custom Cakes

(Order Form Can Be Found At The Bottom Of This Page)

What's In A Cake?

Your cake can include up to three of any of our current flavors of Ice Cream! We would be happy to add a layer of chocolate, yellow, or marble cake at the bottom for an additional charge. The cake is approximately 1/4 inch thick. You may also choose an edible image
for an additional charge, please email us your desired image to Cakes@theplushhorse.com

Last day to order custom cakes this week is...
Thursdays at noon for the upcoming weekend.

Pony Sheet  $35

Serves 8-10

 

1/2 Sheet Cake  $75
Serves 40 - 44

 

1/4 Sheet Cake  $57
Serves 20 - 24

Baby Cake  $11

Serves 1 - 2

 

6" Cake  $30

Serves 6 - 8

 

9" Cake  $48

Serves 16-20

9" Pie  $18-22
Serves 10-12

 

Specialty  Shape 

~Heart  **call for                     price. 

Our Current CUSTOM Decoration Will Include:

Ice Cream only (no cake)


- Up To 3 Flavors (Up to 2 Flavors For Mini Cakes). Sheet Cakes Will Have Flavors Side By Side ONLY

-
 (Whip Cream is Dairy Free. Contains Soy)

- Your custom greeting

- Specific colored border only or sprinkles.
(Border made with whip cream only)

- Candy add-on upon request
(extra charge per cake size).

- Edible image upon request
(extra charge per cake size).

Flavors

  • Coffee

  • Cookie Dough

  • Cookies & Cream

  • Cookie Monster

  • Cotton Candy

  • Dark Chocolate

  • English Toffee

  • Hawaiian Delight

  • Honey Lavendar

  • Jameson Gelato

  • Maple Nut seasonal

  • Mint Chip

  • Moose Tracks

  • Peach

  • Peppermint

  • Pistachio Nut

  • Pralines and Cream

  • Rocky Road

  • Rum Raisin

  • Strawberry

  • Strawberry Cheesecake

  • Superman

  • Vanilla

  • Vanilla NSA(No Sugar Added)

  • Vanilla Malt

  • DAIRY FREE - extra charge

    NSA = No Sugar Added

Whip Cream topping contains: SOY

Flavors In Pink Change Seasonally. Call for Availability.

**See our FLAVOR PAGE for more seasonal flavors!

  • Almond Amaretto

  • Apple Pie

  • Bailey's Gelato

  • Banana

  • Banana Fudge Gelato

  • Black Cherry

  • Black Walnut

  • Blue Moon

  • Brownie Batter

  • Bubble Gum

  • Butter Finger

  • Butter Pecan

  • Butter Pecan NSA(No Sugar Added)

  • Cake Batter

  • Cappuccino

  • Caramel Sea Salt Gelato

  • Cherry Vanilla

  • Chocolate

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Chocolate Chocolate Chip

  • Chocolate Hazelnut

  • Chocolate Malt

  • Chocolate Mousse

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter

  • Coconut Gelato

  • Coconut Fudge Gelato

  • Cinnamon

For DAIRY-FREE OPTIONS
Email us for a quote at
cakes@theplushhorse.com

*ONLINE ORDERS REQUIRE AT LEAST 48-72 HOURS*

*CUSTOM ORDER CUT-OFF

Thursdays at 12 noon
(cut -off time & day may change throughout the year)
 

Closed Mondays thru February
After Monday we do have a variety of displays for the rest of the week! 
 

Pick Up Inside At Palos Park

ALLERGIES? 
Let us know upon ordering so that we can properly accommodate your needs.

*Our product is processed on machinery that was used to process products containing Eggs, Peanuts, Tree Nuts, Wheat, Barley and Rye..

*We are not a 100% Allergy free establishment.


If You Need Help, Call us at 708-448-0550

Custom Cake Online Order Form

 (Call For All Orders Placed After 10am On Fridays)

(PALOS PARK 11am-8pm)

(CALL OR EMAIL FOR EDIBLE IMAGE)

*Please We Are Not A 100% Allergy-Free Establishment. Not Recommended For Life-Threatening Allergies. Allergy List Can Be Found At The Bottom Of This Page

Extra Topping - call for pricing

 Thank you for your order! An email confirmation will be sent to you within 24-48 hours.If you would like to pay in advance for your order please call 708-448-0550 11am-5pm**Depending on custom requests.

CUSTOM CAKE FORM CURRENTLY DOWN!

WE APOLOGIZE FOR ANY INCONVENIENCE. PLEASE CALL 708-448-0550 TO PLACE YOUR CUSTOM CAKE ORDER.

bottom of page