Happy Birthday Cake

Order a custom cake!
48 hours in advance with your
ice cream selections - up to 3 flavors.
(mini cakes up to 2 flavors).
All Sheet cakes will be side by side only.

   We do offer a variety of displays
available for a quick pick-up! 

Call us at 708-448-0550
and a cashier will be happy
to assist you.

Please NOTE we are CLOSED on MONDAYS

Thank you! 

6" with flower crescent
6" with flower crescent

press to zoom
6" with Rosettes
6" with Rosettes

press to zoom
Brownie Batter pony sheet
Brownie Batter pony sheet


press to zoom
6" with flower crescent
6" with flower crescent

press to zoom
Our current CUSTOM decoration will include:
White cake with whip cream. 
Whip cream is dairy free - contains Soy.
- Your custom greeting.-Specific colored border only or sprinkles. 
- Candy add-on upon request (extra charge per cake size).
- Edible image upon request (extra charge per cake size).
- Thank you! 
(Border made with whip cream only) 

Please call if you have any questions 708-448-0550 Ready-made cakes are available in-store for quick pick up! 


*NOTE our ready-made display cakes do not include cake.

Let us know upon ordering so that we can properly accommodate your needs.

What's in a cake?

Your cake can include up to three of any of our current flavors! We would be happy to add a layer of chocolate, yellow, or marble cake at the bottom for an additional charge. The cake is approximately 1/4 inch thick. You may also choose an edible image please email us your desired image to Cakes@theplushhorse.com

Pony Sheet

Serves 10-12


1/2 Sheet Cake
Serves 40 - 44


1/4 Sheet Cake
Serves 20 - 24

Baby Cake

Serves 1 - 2


6" Cake

Serves 6 - 8


9" Cake

Serves 16-20

9" Pie
Serves 10-12


Specialty  Shape 


Wednesdays 12 noon
to be picked up Fri, Sat or Sun.
After Wednesday we do have a variety of displays for the week! Call us or view on the MORE... tab.

 PLEASE email us for a quote at
~ Flavors based on availability ~


*For the most updated list of flavors

view the Ice Cream Flavor page on the home page.

               Based on Availability

  • Almond Amaretto

  • Apple Pie

  • Bailey's Gelato

  • Banana - seasonal

  • Banana Fudge Gelato

  • Black Cherry

  • Black Walnut

  • Blue Moon

  • Brownie Batter

  • Bubble Gum

  • Butter Finger

  • Butter Pecan

  • Butter Pecan NSA(No Sugar Added)

  • Cake Batter

  • Cappuccino

  • Caramel Sea Salt Gelato

  • Cherry Vanilla

  • Chocolate

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Chocolate Chocolate Chip

  • Chocolate Hazelnut

  • Chocolate Malt

  • Chocolate Mousse

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter

  • Coconut Gelato

  • Coconut Fudge Gelato

  • Cinnamon

  • Coffee

  • Cookie Dough

  • Cookies & Cream

  • Cookie Monster

  • Cotton Candy

  • Dark Chocolate

  • English Toffee

  • Hawaiian Delight

  • Honey Lavendar

  • Jameson Gelato

  • Maple Nut seasonal

  • Mint Chip

  • Moose Tracks

  • Peach

  • Peppermint

  • Pistachio Nut

  • Pralines and Cream

  • Rocky Road

  • Rum Raisin

  • Strawberry

  • Strawberry Cheesecake

  • Superman

  • Vanilla

  • Vanilla NSA(No Sugar Added)

  • Vanilla Malt

  • DAIRY FREE - extra charge

    NSA = No Sugar Added

Whip Cream topping contains: SOY




     GO TO...

    our FLAVORS & CAKES tab "IceCream Flavors" 

 for the updated list!

*Seasonal flavors- please call for availability


Don't see your

favorite flavor?

Give us a call!


            Please email Images to cakes@theplushhorse.com
                        or if you have any questions.

Allergies*Our product is processed on machinery that was used to process products containing Eggs, Peanuts, Tree Nuts, Wheat, Barley and Rye..

We are not a 100% Allergy free establishment.

  Pick up is at PALOS PARK LOCATION only.